The endless reinvention of junk food

From reformulating recipes to embracing the language of wellness, Big Food has mastered the art of survival. The ingredients may change, but the strategy remains the same: keep us coming back.

In the spring of 2014, the most curious invitation came my way. Nestlé, the processed food giant, asked me to address a gathering of the sixty or so men and women who led its research and development organization. This was rather startling given that the book I just wrote, Salt Sugar Fat, singled out one of their biggest sellers, the Hot Pocket, as a poster child for the kind of eating that got us into so much trouble: cheap, convenient, mindless.

The company’s move to also sell liquid-food products to people who undergo bariatric surgery for obesity seemed, well, guileful at best. “Gorge on Hot Pockets,” I wrote. “Drink Peptamen through a tube.”

At the time, Nestlé had a new and enthusiastic head of R&D who said it was turning over a new leaf, and that having me run through all the bad stuff it had done would help its people now better focus on doing good. So, I flew to Switzerland, delivered a Cliff Notes version of my 90-minute talk to some polite applause, and then spent two days roaming the company’s laboratories where I was forced to rethink my calculus on just what it is about processed food that drives us so mad with desire.

Until then, I had focused on salt, sugar, and fat as the unholy trinity used by the industry to make its products alluring. The science in this was certainly extraordinary. For sugar, the legendary Howard Moskowitz showed me the precise engineering that went into designing formulas that generated what he called the bliss point for sweetness to send us over the moon and their products flying off the shelves. And when the food manufacturers then marched around the grocery store adding sugar and bliss points to things that had never been sweet – bread, yogurt, spaghetti sauce – we came to expect sweetness in everything we ate. Ditto their use of salt for what they called its flavour burst, and fats for that lusciousness called mouthfeel. The power of this trio, which one executive referred to as the company jewels, meant that the part of the store where nutritionists agree we should all be spending more time — the produce aisle, with its bitter and sour flavour notes — didn’t stand a chance in courting us.

Yet even as I was writing that narrative, the processed food industry’s campaign to upstage the produce aisle by reshaping our likes and dislikes was hitting a bump. We began catching on. Enough people were reading the fine print on product labels to see just how much salt, sugar and fat was being used, and with sales of the most loaded products starting to slip, the food manufacturers were now scrambling to put up some less scary numbers.

Nestlé led the way with its elegant laboratory complex in the bucolic hills of Lausanne on Lake Geneva. Dozens of PhD scientists were working to better understand what draws us to food, and much of their focus was now trained on reducing their reliance on the big three additives to pull us in. One team laboured to reduce the overall salt content of their products by concentrating it on the surface where we tasted it best. Another was testing sugar substitutes. A third showed me a patented trick for how fat globules could be flattened out for more surface area, thus delivering more mouthfeel for less actual fat.

Not to be outdone, the whole industry began issuing new formulations with product labels that boasted of having less sugar, less fat, less salt. Yet, if anything, our dependence on processed food, and the health disaster that it brings, only seemed to grow.

I began to wonder if maybe the most powerful weapon these companies have in controlling our eating habits is their ability to duck, dodge and out-maneuver any danger that comes their way. And mostly they do this by tweaking their formulas just enough to quell the latest public angst.

When high fructose corn syrup got singled out for scorn, companies switched to sugar made from beets or cane. Worries about seed oil (unfounded, according to nutritionists I trust) prompted conversions to beef tallow. You could almost hear the sigh of relief among the makers of sugary breakfast cereal when the Make America Healthy Again movement embraced by Donald Trump singled out artificial dyes as the biggest problem to solve. Even Skittles merely switched over to natural colourings and got a nice, false halo of health for their otherwise nutritionally-bankrupt candy.

The industry is even now moving to steal the language of wholesome food, with regeneration and childhood memories, and small farmers and protein popping up in junk food ads. Without real intervention from government regulators looking out for the health and wellbeing of people, the growing public alarm about processed and convenience food is just a game for this industry, and one that it plays really well.

Most viewed

Globalization is over. The era of geoeconomics has begun

Trade, technology and industrial policy have become instruments of geopolitical power. Former ambassador Giorgio Starace explains the era of geoeconomics: how the US, China and Europe compete over chips and AI, and why Europe needs an industrial policy at EU level.

How clowns defeated hate and what it teaches us about fighting Trump

In May 2007 an army of clowns outnumbered white supremacists at a Knoxville KKK rally, turning ‘white power’ into ‘white flour’ and ‘wife power’. Randy Fertel argues that imagination, humour and ridicule remain sharp tools against Trump.

War, housing, welfare: what Europe’s young socialists want from their parties

Young activists in Europe's social democratic parties do not always toe the line of the political movements they have chosen to join. Sometimes they...